← ISO 27001: Critical success factors ISO 27001

ISO 27001: Assurance and Audit

Internal audit (clause 9.2)

Tom Whipp · 31 October 2026 · 3 min read

Part of ISO 27001: Critical success factors, a series on building a management system that reflects how your organisation really runs.

What it is

Assurance is how you check, independently, that the ISMS is working. Internal audit is the part the standard requires; customer due diligence, independent control testing and the certification audits themselves are all forms of assurance too.

Internal audit covers the whole management system, not just the controls. A forum that never meets, or a risk register nobody updates, is as much an audit finding as a control that doesn't operate.

What the standard asks

Clause 9.2 requires internal audits at planned intervals to show whether the ISMS conforms to your own requirements and to the standard, and whether it's effectively implemented and maintained. You need:

  • an audit programme setting frequency, methods, responsibilities, planning and reporting, taking account of the importance of the processes and the results of previous audits
  • defined criteria and scope for each audit
  • auditors chosen to ensure objectivity and impartiality
  • results reported to the relevant management
  • documented evidence of the programme and the results

What good looks like

  • A programme that covers clauses 4 to 10 and a sample of controls over the certification cycle, with more attention where risk or past findings point.
  • Independence, as far as you can get it. Ideally auditors don't audit their own work. In a small organisation that can mean a colleague from another team or an external auditor for part of the programme. Where it genuinely can't be avoided, the conflict is recorded, accepted by leadership and kept as small as possible.
  • Facts first. Findings are based on evidence both sides can agree on before anyone debates what they mean.
  • Findings go into the improvement plan with owners and dates, and the forum sees them.
  • Timing that leaves room to act. The internal audit lands early enough before certification for findings to be addressed.

Evidence an auditor will ask for

  • The internal audit programme and plans
  • Audit reports and findings
  • Corrective actions raised from findings, and their status
  • Forum minutes showing audit results were reviewed

Common failure modes

  • Self-audit left unmanaged. In a small organisation the person who built the ISMS may be the only one who knows it well enough to audit it. That can be unavoidable, but it's a conflict of interest to manage rather than ignore. Record it, have leadership accept it, and reduce it where you can: ask a colleague to audit the parts you built most directly, bring in an external auditor for part of the programme, or swap audits with a peer organisation.
  • Annex A only. Audits that test controls but never look at management review, risk assessment or objectives miss the core of the standard.
  • Findings reworded away. Debating wording until the finding disappears teaches the organisation nothing.
  • Audit the week before certification. Findings arrive with no time to act, and the certification auditor sees an untouched list.

How it connects

Feeds from

Feeds into

Where it sits in the plan

Stage: Check. The first internal audit is part of the first Check, alongside the first full management review. Before the main certification audit, certification bodies will normally expect to see at least one of each, as part of the evidence that the ISMS has been running long enough. After that, the programme rotates through the scope across each three-year certification cycle.

The plan in the main article shows how this fits with everything else, and the bootstrapping guide covers each stage in detail.

Resources


Tom Whipp is the founder of RiskQuilt. He spent around thirty years in cyber and technology risk in UK financial services, including CISO and Director of Technology Risk roles.

Ready to leave the spreadsheets behind?

Start your free trial today. No credit card required. No sales call. Your data, your platform, in minutes.